Vehicles with passengers more likely to be searched by police, according to UTSA research
(Aug. 12, 2015) -- Police officers’ actions are generally subject to a myriad of mandatory policies, protocols, and laws. But there is one aspect of the job that gives officers a lot of discretionary flexibility: routine traffic stops.
Rob Tillyer, associate professor in the Department of Criminal Justice and College of Public Policy at UTSA, studies the decision-making processes of criminal justice professionals, including police officers, and the use of officer discretion within traffic stops, in particular.
Traffic stops are the most common type of police-citizen interaction. Tillyer and his colleague, Charles F. Klahm IV, assistant professor of criminal justice at Wayne State University, pored over a year’s worth of traffic stop data and reports from a large, urban and majority Hispanic city in Texas.
The researchers compared stops that ended in a discretionary search of the vehicle or citizen to those that did not end in a discretionary search to determine similarities and correlations. In the course of their research, they examined 187,412 traffic stops initiated by police officers in a city of roughly 1.5 million residents served by a police force of approximately 2,000 sworn officers.
“Police officers have a lot of discretionary freedom during traffic stops, for better or worse,” said Tillyer. “Depending on legal justification and department protocols, they can let a driver leave with a ticket or a warning, ask to search a vehicle, or, if given probable cause, legally search the vehicle regardless of driver permission. They can also arrest the driver.”
While mandatory policies (i.e., department regulations that limit officer discretion) may vary slightly between jurisdictions, traffic stops generally afford police officers the freedom to enforce the law however they deem necessary within the confines of the law.
The researchers found that officers were more likely to search a vehicle for discretionary reasons in situations where more than one passenger of any demographic was present.
“There are several possible reasons why police officers may feel the need to search vehicles with passengers more often,” Tillyer said. “For one, officer safety is a paramount consideration within these situations. Alternatively, it could be an issue of officers asserting authority among a group, and it isn’t uncommon for delinquency or criminal offending to occur in a group-related setting.”
With regard to the latter explanation, the “Group Hazard Hypothesis” is a line of research in criminal justice circles dating back to the 1920s that suggests that criminal behavior often involves multiple offenders. In a 1971 study, researchers found that 65 percent of juvenile violations involved two or more participants.
In light of this, Tillyer suggests it is plausible that officers might possess heightened suspicion when engaged in a traffic stop involving multiple occupants.
Tillyer and Klahm hope this study will add to the discussion about the importance of considering external variables in research concerning police discretion and the importance of accura te reporting by police departments and citizens.
“Discretionary Searches, the Impact of Passengers, and the Implications for Police-Minority Encounters” is forthcoming in the Criminal Justice Review.
-----------------------------
Learn more about the UTSA College of Public Policy
Connect online at Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram.
Events
The UTSA Office of Undergraduate is proud to celebrate National Undergraduate Research with an annual event sponsored by the (OUR) featuring students will showcase undergraduate student research and creative endeavors from all disciplines across campus.
Various LocationsAsian Fanfair is an event that highlights our APIDA (Asian Pacific Islander Desi American) identities on campus. The event will feature performances from our AAPI interest Student Organizations, a tabling fair, and some cultural cuisine.
Student Union Paseo, Main CampusJoin us for a day dedicated to supporting and empowering our UTSA veterans! We're excited to announce our upcoming resource fair, designed specifically to ensure that our veteran students have access to the resources and networking opportunities they need to thrive in their academic and post-military lives.
Student Union Lawn, Main CampusThis workshop will introduce participants to the basics of text analysis using Python and Jupyter Notebook on the Constellate Lab platform. We will create datasets in Constellate to analyze patterns, trends, and relationships of contents and more.
John Peace Library (JPL 3.02.32), Main CampusWhat would award-winning writing professor Diane Abdo say if it were her last lecture? Join us for our annual Last Lecture series on Wednesday April 17.
Multipurpose Room (BSE 2.102), Main CampusDía en la Sombrilla, formerly Fiesta UTSA, is a festival hosted each spring as a part of Fiesta® San Antonio events. Sponsored by Roadrunner Productions, the event features music, food, confetti, games, event t-shirts, and more.
Sombrilla Plaza and Central Plaza, Main CampusFiesta Arts Fair features contemporary art from more than 100 artists from across the U.S., Fiesta favorite foods, drinks, live music by local and regional performers, and a Young Artists Garden providing opportunities for budding artists to learn, explore and express their creativity.
UTSA Southwest Campus