UTSA professor's new study questions the influence of CEOs
(Oct. 27, 2015) — A board of directors oversees the governance of public companies, but how much influence do CEOs have in the nomination process for directors? According to recent research by UTSA accounting faculty member Zhongxia Ye and her colleagues at Kennesaw State University, they found that CEO influence can vary widely.
Given the need for board member independence, Ye’s research is vital because CEO influence can be associated with adverse governance or accounting outcomes.
“Sarbanes-Oxley requires auditing and other committee members to be independent,” said Ye, whose research focuses on corporate governance and internal controls. “In reality, they may not be.”
Following up on past research that explored board of directors relationships, Ye’s work examined the director nomination process employed by board of directors nominating committees based on 20 in-depth interviews of U.S. public company nominating committee members.
“The interview process was so important,” said Ye. “Interview-based research provides us with a ‘black box’ of information that is not typically found in research studies.”
The study examined the extent of influence that the CEO had over the committee process; the extent to which the committee process was formalized; and examined the social ties between the interviewees and the CEO.
“What surprised us was that CEOs do have a lot of influence over the process,” said Ye.
The study yielded three findings. First, they found evidence that CEO influence was greater when the potential nominees had more experience serving on board of directors. Next, they found that CEO influence was greater when retirees served on the nominating committees. Finally, more influence was found for larger companies with greater revenues.
“Based on our findings, we’d encourage auditors to talk with independent board members about the CEO’s role in director nominations, since such influence can impact the internal control process,” said Ye.
In their sample, candidates nominated by the CEO were approved 36 percent of the time. But, they also found that CEO influence over the nominating process has declined over the years.
“This information is rich and can benefit practitioners,” said Ye. “I like to do work that has an impact on practice. And, accounting is the language of business.”
The study, “The Nominating Committee Process: A Qualitative Examination of Board Independence and Formalization,” appears in Contemporary Accounting Research.
Learn more about the College of Business.
Interested in wellbeing programs, events and resources? Every Wednesday at noon you can stop by virtually and ask any questions you may have about Student Health Services, Counseling and Mental Health Services, and the PEACE office.Virtual Event
Learn more about Omada Health, a free healthy living program available to eligible UTSELECT members. This will be a live webinar in honor of National Nutrition Month (March) and Diabetes Alert Day (March 23). Get your questions answered and find out if Omada is right for youVirtual Event
Join our Health Education team and our Relationship Advocate as we discuss all things Sexual Health, STIs, Healthy Relationships, and more! This is your chance to learn what wasn't taught in High School! You can even submit questions anonymously and we'll answer them.Virtual Event
Session for social scientists on how to identify and understand which programs within NSF and NIH fund social sciences, what reviewers are typically looking for, and common mistakes to avoid. The presenter will also cover how to identify private foundations that may be interested in funding your social science research.Virtual Event
Join our Health Educators as we go over a very brief and basic presentation over proper nutrition, reading food labels, and portion sizes.Virtual Event
Open to members of the LGBTQ in all stages of identity formation from questioning to integration who seek a safe place to discuss issues.Virtual Event
General Assembly is a time when all members and officers of SGA come together to discuss important issues regarding UTSA and finding solutions through legislation or initiatives. Important updates are regularly given by SGA officers, UTSA administrators, or special guests. Our meetings are open to the public and are held on a weekly basis.Virtual Event